Monday, October 10, 2005

EU: Nepal at risk of collapse


Kathmandu, 9 October
BBC South Asia

Nepal has seen many political protests in recent months. A European Union delegation on a visit to Nepal says the country is in danger of political collapse.
EU delegation leader, Tom Phillips, said the failure of constitutional forces could lead to a breakdown of government institutions.
King Gyanendra seized direct power in February saying politicians had failed to tackle the insurgency by Maoists.
The EU team also accused the Maoists of continuing to recruit child soldiers despite calling a ceasefire last month.
Full story at http://news.bbc.co.uk/1/hi/world/south_asia/4314792.stm

Sunday, October 09, 2005

God in the stones

Reprinted from Indian Express, Oct. 9 by Sudheendra Kulkarni

What struck me was that before the team began the day’s work, a woman performed a small puja on the stone, smeared it with the auspicious yellow and red powder, broke it with a ceremonial strike and then everybody went about their respective tasks. I asked the woman why she did it. In her own earthy Marathi, she replied, ‘‘This is not a mere stone for us. There is divinity in it. This stone feeds us. It also makes your cars run smoothly on the road.’’

full story at:
http://www.indianexpress.com/full_story.php?content_id=79656

Saturday, October 08, 2005

Yo, lama


At the risk of sounding like a jerk, being a lama is not that big a deal. This realization becomes more clear after spending time in a Tibetan community. Anybody with a sponsor who can stay in school 12 years can be a lama - and for most Asians it seems to be second nature to stay in school, follow orders, don't ask questions, and get that piece of paper. Then you get the title "lama." (It would be a much bigger challenge for a Westerner.) They are walking the streets here, so they no longer seem exotic. I shared a taxi with one last night who kept hitting on me (and this one was a shaven monk in robes). Then there was the one who told me he wanted my body - and that was standing in front of the Maitreya statue in the lakhang of his monastery. Dharmsala is full of Tibetan guys hoping to get a foreign wife and a green card, trading on the Tibetan mystique the same way Indians did in the 60s and 70s.

My friend maintains that part of this (extracurricular monk behavior) is because so many monks are now Bhutanese and Nepalese, that the Tibetans are "different." Somehow, considering the more relaxed Tibetan attitudes toward sexuality, I doubt this. To be fair, I guess there are lamas and then there are Lamas. Also, definition of the word Lama seems to vary between the Buddhist schools. In some places anyone in robes is called Lama; in others only a current incarnation of a previously highly evolved soul gets this title.

Most of the Western Buddhists I meet here appear to be very miserable people. Is that what happens when you focus on Emptiness so much? I confess that I don't find it a terribly motivating concept. A great deal of the Baby Buddhists' motivation appears to be Being Part of Something Cool, particularly the younger ones who got involved once Tibetan Buddhism was already trendy. But they're just so gosh-darn cute and squeaky-clean "dharmic." I love the way they know nothing about Hinduism and the fact that Buddhism came from Hinduism (as much a shock to some of them as, say, telling most Christians that Jesus was actually a Jew.) They also assume an innate piousness on the part of ethnic Tibetans, who to me appear nothing if not terminally tough and practical.
KATHMANDU DIARIES
News from the Landlocked Insurgency-Wracked Isolated
Perched-Precariously-Between-Two-Superpowers
Middle Mountain Kingdom


Displaced not returning home for Dasain
DIPAYAL, Nepal, Oct 8: Displaced people living in the district HQ here have decided not to return to their villages for Dasain festival. They say that the villages are no longer safe even after the unilateral declaration of cease-fire by Maoists.
...They fear that the ceasefire may break down any time. However, they say that they would return to their villages if the government reciprocates the cease-fire.

"Maoist activities continue unabated in the villages. The government has not reciprocated their ceasefire declaration. We don't believe that we will be able to live safely in the villages, " said Khadga Bohara, one of the displaced.


Many of the displaced came to the district headquarters after Maoists beat them, looted their property and set fire to their houses.

Acording to district police office, 53 displaced families are living in the HQ. Many youth who left for India, fearing Maoist abuse, have also not returned to the villages. In previous years, the bus stand here used to bustle with youngsters returning home at this time of year. (Kathmandu Post)

And in a somewhat related story to the South:
PATNA, Bihar, Oct 8: Suspected Maoist rebels set off a land mine in eastern India on Saturday, klling seven policemen, a police official said.

(Kathmandu Post)

Women become judges in Kaski
KASKI, Oct 8: Women of Pumdibumdhi VDC have become judges of their own village, deciding all cases pertaining to domestic violence. Today all cases relating to domestic violence must first pass through the Women Judiciary Forum (WJF). It requires the forum's approval if the cases are to be referred to a higher court of appeal, or the police.

Baral (of WJF) said that after the women started vetting the cases, male members have become wary of females in the villages.... According to a study commissioned by the Habitat Research, Pumdibhumdi was notorious for th largest number of domestic violence cases in Kaski, followed by Sarangkot and Rupakot in the district. After the campaign by women, the situation has reversed.

full stories: http://www.kantipuronline.com/paper.php?id=2

Friday, October 07, 2005

Namaste Not


Living full-time in Asia, one grows weary of newcomers' romantic ideas.

Where did this idea come from - that "Namaste" means "The god within me honours the god within you," or some other Orientalist, new age spin? This is an imputed meaning; there is nothing in the literal translation to indicated anythng other than this: I Bow To You. I maintain that this is a myth (about 'honouring the god') fostered by foreigners. Bowing is just a pan-Asian cultural norm, there is nothing especially spiritual about it. In fact, quite the opposite. I don't think *most* Hindus bow for any reason other than ingrained subordination.

Sanskrit is not a mysterious, ancient language but one I was taught as a conversational, modern one, as part of the Samskrita Bharati Sanskrit revival programme. In case you think I was instructed by secular humanists, my first teacher was a practicing Hindu and Indian nationalist. Namaste means "I bow to you" (I believe the Te ending makes it To You, I bow would be namaami) just like "janaami" means "I know."

Okay, everyone bowing is not doing so out of sheer fear. Great masters like Amma may bow for one reason, average people for another. But Amma doesn't bow to everyone and everything because she is Hindu, she bows because she is realized and sees God in everything and everyone. I think realized beings everywhere would do the same, Hindu, Buddhist, whatever.

The fact that they are Hindu has nothing to do with it, IMHO. The average Brahmin (unless he is some kind of liberal like Vivekananda) will never, ever bow to another Hindu of lower caste, and that goes for most castes on down (Kshatryia wouldn't bow to a Vaishya, etc). What happens, you may ask, if a Brahmin has a boss or superior of a lower caste? Conveniently, this doesn't happen very often (three guesses as to why?).

The average Indian, Hindu or otherwise, does not go around honouring the god in everyone and everything else. They live in fear of power, and the bowing is a reflection of that. If you want to call that respect, well, I have a different definition of respect. It may be respect, but it's not mutual.

It's funny to watch the doormen, waiters, and other servicepeople here greet guests with Namaste and a slight bow, and watch the foreigners return this. The foreigners don't understand that this is inappropriate. In fact, it lowers the workers' view of the foreigners. (what are they, stupid, bowing to a peon?) The workers are the workers, and don't expect this gesture to be returned - after all, we are not subservient to them. Their world is a strictly hierarchical one and we bewilder them by not knowing "our place." Nepalis and Indians never make this mistake. They just kind of slightly nod and keep doing, which is all that is expected of them. There is no mutual respect in Indian culture - it's all top down !

How much of this has to do with Hindu values, how much is just Indian culture, who knows? The fact is that most of the people doing this are Hindus by birth, and this is how they behave. If bowing to the god in everyone is in fact a Hindu value, they're not practicing it.

Watch they way people communicate. They don't have a dialogue. Superiors give orders and underlings follow. Parents tell their kids what to do and the kids do it. Husbands give orders and wives follow. The idea of honouring everyone equally is a Western one.


My observations about India and Hinduism come from living in India, practicing Hinduism and observing others doing the same. What's written in books, by either foreigners or Indian intellectuals, doesn't have much bearing on this (except as an amusing contrast sometimes!).

I think everyone coming from the West to study Hinduism should close their books and go observe behavior in temples, pujas, homes, markets and so forth. That is where Hinduism is practiced. Whether it's practiced correctly or not is another question.